Watch the Replay
Transcript
David Grau Jr.: Welcome, everyone, to today’s session. I’m David Grau Jr., President of Succession Resource Group, and I have the pleasure of hosting today’s session. I will give everyone just a few more minutes to get, not logged in, but set up in the Zoom webinar interface. It always takes just a second.
While you all are getting in and settled, welcome to our session today, which you can see titled on screen here, and you received the email invite, obviously: Close Strong, Start Fast. This is the Owner’s Year-End Succession Playbook. So we’re gonna hit on top priorities, things to be focusing on as advisors, but in general, as small business owners. Things that you can get wrapped up, and that should, I think, be a priority for Q4. And what can we get knocked out in Q1? What are the top priorities? What should we do now? What can wait till Q1? And I’ll even touch on one or two things that would be beyond Q1, but that I want you to start thinking about now, because I know they will be impactful to your businesses.
So, just to get us started here, a little bit of housekeeping while you all get settled. I appreciate you taking the time out of your busy schedules to join us here. Housekeeping items: this session is being recorded. You will get it automatically via email tomorrow in your inbox, so watch for that in case you want to listen to the replay, review anything that we talked about here today, or share it with anybody that you know needs to hear this message, or the to-dos and takeaways we’re gonna be talking about today. So you’ll get that automatically tomorrow.
The slides that I’m gonna be walking you through here today have some data, statistics, and obviously some recommendations. So if you’d like a copy of those slides, they are available. Just reply back to our team. You’ll be hearing from probably Craig or Sabrina shortly after the session anyway, via email, or they may call you and leave you a voicemail. So if you want a copy of the slides, just let them know. Happy to share those with you.
Last two items. There is a Q&A panel built in here. I do encourage you to use it. I’ll try to save some time at the end for questions, but if you’ve attended any of these webinars before, and any of my team members listening here know this, if it’s an hour-long session, we budget for 45 minutes, and somehow I fill 50 to 55 minutes of it every time. So, best efforts here to save time for questions at the end, but we do encourage you to ask questions during the session. We’ve done this before, it’s definitely not my first rodeo, and I will be watching and moderating, as well as other team members. So if we can get your questions answered in the Q&A chat panel, we’ll do that. If I can weave your question in organically as we’re talking here together today, I’ll do that as well. I know you’re on mute, I know you’re sitting back listening, taking this all in, but we do still want to try to keep this as interactive as possible, and that Q&A panel is how we do it. So again, I’ll answer questions at the end, and if I can get to them during the session, I’ll be watching.
Last but not least is poll questions. We only have one poll, and you’ll see that coming up right about now, or shortly here in a second. The questions in our one poll are hopefully all softball questions for you. We encourage you to take a second and answer them. I’ll press on with the presentation, obviously, but it really does help us in terms of bringing you better content that’s more topical. I can even adjust a little bit on the fly, because our moderator here will publish the results, which you can then see, and I can see, and I’ll use that today a bit, where it makes sense to weave it in.
But we also use it for our content planning, bringing you quality content. I mean, not just webinars, obviously. It will certainly help inform the webinars we’ll be doing for you in 2027, based on your answers, but also even just the content we put together: case studies, white papers, articles, checklists. If we know where you’re at in this journey, and where your priorities lie, then we can do a better job of bringing you resources and information that meet you where you’re at.
So, that’s it for the housekeeping. Again, if you were late getting in, the session’s recorded, and you’ll get that automatically tomorrow. Slides are available upon request, just let our team know. Q&A panel, do use it. I’ll be watching it, as will our moderators. And then the poll question, obviously, that one’s already taken care of. So, without further ado, let’s dive in.
David Grau Jr.: A little bit of background here, real quick. I said that was the end of the housekeeping. One more slide of housekeeping: SRG. So, I’m David Grau, President of Succession Resource Group. We’ve got a team of 25 professionals, including myself, spread around the country. We tell folks we know a lot about a little. We really only deal with things that impact the value, the equity, in your business.
Obviously, we’re Succession Resource Group, so we’re gonna have a succession lens on it. But that’s important, because it means everything that we do and talk about is hopefully taking the same angle of attack that you are, and that is thinking about how these things impact your eventual exit. Start with the end in mind. Even if you’re 40 years old, a CFP, in growth mode, a fee-only RIA, maybe you’re affiliated with a broker-dealer, dually registered, or hybrid. Either way, succession planning done right really is more about growing than it is going.
But I do also want to make sure that we can focus on the going part, because, shoot, I don’t care what study you look at or what talking head you listen to, us included, obviously, hence the meeting today. Your business is probably, if not your most valuable asset, certainly one of your most valuable assets. So I want to spend time today talking about ways that we can optimize that and get the most value for it when the time comes.
So, that’s what we do in a nutshell: a bunch of industry experts here that have been doing it a really long time. I think that is the one differentiator as you contemplate eventually finding somebody to help you work through the things I’m going to talk about today. You will not find a team that has, A, more dedication, but we can all say that. You won’t find a team that has more experience, more time in the saddle working with firms like yours. They’re not out there. There are some great, really smart investment bankers that are great on the investment banking side, if you end up getting to a point where you just want to pull the ripcord and sell it to one of the firms that they represent. That’s a good option. They’re smart. We know those folks. There are one or two other firms that do some of the work that we do, but if you’re looking for a deep bench of talent and thought leadership to make sure you do this right the first time, or redo it right the second time, hopefully not a third, that’s us.
And when we get the chance to work together, I suspect it’ll be because of this alphabet soup here in the middle. We have industry experts that have been consulting for a long time. I think the last time I looked at it, our average tenure for a consultant, our experts here, was like 12 and a half years, and I haven’t looked at it in a while, so it might be higher than that. We’ve been doing it a while, but the nice thing is we can go from talking a good game, the strategy, and the spreadsheets with our project managers and our directors, to then handing it off to our tax and legal crew in-house. We don’t outsource this stuff, we don’t refer you out, we control it end to end. We never sell based on this, but that ends up being a more cost-effective solution for you, and incidentally for us, because we can control the process end to end.
We’ve done this before, it’s not our first rodeo. So the things we’ll talk about today are all things that we do a lot. I’ll pick on, I don’t know, entity planning. We’re gonna try to upgrade your entity, not for where you were or where you are, but for where you’re going. We’ve done this before. We have a lot of form contracts. You don’t need a lot of form contracts, you just need the right one. But the best part is, that means we can start with something that is probably 90% of what you don’t even know you need, and then spend all of our time together refining that last 10%. That’s how we work on most of our projects. It makes it far more efficient, and you get a better result, because you’re starting with something that has been field tested. We’ve done this before. We’ve seen people fight about it. We’ve seen what can go wrong. That’s what you get to start with.
So, that’s us in a nutshell. We’ve been doing this a long time. We started back in 2012 as an organization, and I started doing this back in 2004. So we’ve been around, and we would love the chance to share our wisdom with you, a little bit of that here today. So, let’s dive in.
David Grau Jr.: I’m gonna give you the CliffsNotes version right off the bat. Number one, the stuff we’re trying to get done, hopefully before the end of the year, and I will try to compel you as to why this is a priority, because I know here we are at the beginning of November. We’ve got holidays, and it’s gonna be January 1, 2027, before you know it. A lot of the content we talk about and share is evergreen. This is very timely. So, for Q1 of this year, what do we focus on? And then, backing up from that, what are we gonna maybe try to get done by the end of this year, if I’m sitting in your shoes?
Number one: contingency plan, signed and funded. And funded doesn’t necessarily mean putting a bunch of money away, or getting life insurance or disability insurance. Funded can just mean that we’ve thought through how this thing would be funded in the future, and we know it works. So I say contingency plan, and I’ll unpack that more later, but that could be a buy-sell, a death and disability plan, contingency, continuity, six of one, half a dozen of the other. All different terms for the same thing. It’s your disaster plan. You’re gone tomorrow. What do we do? Who takes over? How much does your estate get for your most valuable asset?
Number two is get your employment agreements updated and optimized, or if you haven’t done that yet, let’s get it in writing. And really, again, I get it, it’s November, we’ve got two months, and barely even that, call it six weeks. How are we gonna get all this stuff done? Well, the contingency plan we can do pretty quick. You need to help us with some answers to questions, but we’ll make sure you understand the scope of the options and the pros and cons of each, so it’s pretty efficient for you. On the employment agreements, we don’t have to do it with everybody, although we can still do that pretty quickly. The employment agreements we’re really focused on are with your client-facing advisory staff. Let’s focus on that by the end of the year, and I’ll talk about why.
The last one is to think about getting the compensation plan nailed down for 2027. Now, again, you may roll it out and deploy it at some point in mid-2027, but get it done, get it ready, and start talking about it.
And then we can shift to the Q1 stuff, the beginning of next year, and that is the entity formation or re-formation, depending on where you’re at with that process. Then the equity sharing plan, again, just getting it scoped out, and then potentially being ready to launch it. Whether you launch it or not is entirely up to you, but I do want to make sure that, at the very least, you can launch it, that you’re in a good position to do that.
The last one is valuation. Refresh it, track it every single year, get that done. I’d say maybe February or March, so that’s probably the end of Q1. And I’m just speaking practically. We’ve got hundreds of annual valuation clients that we have the pleasure of doing this work for every single year. You close the books in January, you’re busy, I get it, we are too. You get back from the holidays, you’re getting your priorities set for 2027. The main focus here is that if you close the books in January, maybe start the valuation process with us in February, we can have it back to you in March, and you’re ready for all the other stuff you can start doing with that. So, that’s our roadmap, that’s our goal.
David Grau Jr.: Let’s start with the exit planning component here. I’m going to break it down into two sub-components and tackle each one individually, and I’m going to spend more time on the left-hand side, what I talked about: the contingency plan, planning for the unexpected. Succession planning is great too, and I will talk about that, but I’m going to save it for the end of this section, and I’m going to hit it quickly, because you’re not going to figure out your succession plan by the end of Q1. Amazing as our team might be, and we’ve got great models and spreadsheets and strategies, we can’t get that done by the end of Q1. You wouldn’t want us to, but there’s just too much to do for that. So focus on the left-hand side. Get the contingency plan figured out.
There are five main steps. I’m gonna oversimplify some of this, but for the sake of the conversation, there are really only five steps to create a viable plan. I’ll start on the left: value. You already heard me talk about that. Do the valuation annually, at the very least. Take the average multiples we publish. We can help you create a formula that can be applied. But we do need to figure out the value and be able to hit a moving target.
You’ll see the options I listed there for you. That could be a stated value that you update annually. I’d say that’s probably your best option, but it’s also your worst. I say best option because a stated value is really easy to understand. There’s no room for interpretation, there’s no room for math, or making math errors, or gathering the wrong data. You did your valuation, you say it’s $2.5 million, and that’s the answer until you say otherwise. So it’s really efficient. If you suddenly died tomorrow, and we had to transact on your business and get it moved over to somebody else, and you did a buy-sell agreement with us for death and disability and you put a stated value in, we have no additional math to do. That’s the number. The downside is that very few folks are good about diligently updating that every year, and so it’s going to be wrong, practically speaking.
So then you shift gears to a formula. Formulas work really, really well. They’re also wrong. Because if we did your valuation, and you’re worth $3 million, and you’ve got a million in fees, we can figure out your multiple pretty easily. Your multiple is 3X. Put the 3X multiple into the buy-sell that we’d be helping you create, and we can hit the moving target. So you think, well, how could that be wrong? My revenue grows or shrinks, you’ll apply it to the current revenue, and we’ll be back to the right answer. Kind of. If you update your valuation every year, and you update your multiple each year, sure, you’re gonna be pretty darn close. You’re gonna have a tough time not being accurate. But what most folks do is they do their valuation, we get their multiple, they plug that into their buy-sell, and 10 years later, it’s the same multiple. The market for practices like yours has moved up during that period. The quality of your practice, your book of business, has gotten better or worse. So your multiple changes, but it has a little more longevity to it than the stated value. So it does work. There’s still some math, though, so keep that formula stupid simple. And then you’ve got valuing at the time of a triggering event, which can work. I’ll talk more about that one on the next slide.
Then you have the plan component. We’ve got to figure out a practical way to fund this thing. Life insurance could work, but you’ll see my title on this slide: life insurance is not a plan. Life insurance could be a funding mechanism, it could be a down payment, or you could have no life insurance at all for this plan. Maybe you’re already insured well enough. Maybe you’re uninsurable, or at least uninsurable cost-effectively. Great, we can still put a plan together that’s funded out of cash flow, where your estate gets paid out, or you, if you’re disabled, get paid out, over six, seven, eight years, maybe. You can make it work. It’s pretty hard to not actually have it work.
Then you commit. You write it down. The last ones are that you communicate it. Tell all the key stakeholders. Tell the clients. Share the story, let them know, run through the fire drill: no health issues here, I’m fine, but as a professional planner by trade and by nature, I have a plan. So we communicate that plan, and then we review it periodically.
I cannot tell you how many plans we’ve ended up seeing over the course of the last 20 years I’ve been doing this where folks are surprised when they realize the buy-sell agreement they put together is hopelessly out of date. Maybe it’s not even with somebody they’d want to take over the business anymore. The multiple’s old and stagnant. So just dust it off. If you’re looking at this thinking, I hope he gets on with this presentation, because I already have a death and disability plan, dust it off. You could be right, I’ll move on, I promise. But do review it. Do make sure that whatever plan you have is current, because we deal with a couple of these every single year, and I tell you, even with a well-thought-out plan that’s current, it sucks. It’s a fire sale. It’s workable, but it’s still a disaster by any other measure. If you don’t have a plan that’s current, or you don’t have a plan at all, you’d better hope that your spouse can’t bring you back, because he or she will kill you for doing that to them. So just get the plan in place.
A few other pointers on this topic: value, funding for it, and accounting for the risk. So, if we think about the value of your business, I talked about the formula. Formula is one consideration. It can work. There are pros and cons. It’s not necessarily going to be the end-all, be-all answer for all of you, but it’s definitely a good option.
You’ve got valuing at the time of a triggering event, which sometimes feels like kicking the can down the road, because we’re not actually gonna do a valuation today. I still think it’s a good idea to do it now. So now we’re doing the valuation, and we know you’re worth $3 million, $5 million, $10 million. We’re not putting that valuation into the buy-sell. We’re doing it for educational purposes. We want to have a baseline to compare against and make sure we’re good. But we’re gonna use that as a baseline just for educational, informative purposes only. What we’re gonna put into the actual death and disability plan is that when something happens, we are going to do a valuation.
That’s your best answer, from a purely technical perspective. Why? Because it will consider the current state of your practice and the current market conditions. If the market just tanked and appears to be staying down for the foreseeable future, and that’s what gave you a heart attack and killed you, the business is going to be valued under those conditions. If the business has been growing rapidly in the last 12 to 18 months, we’re gonna value it under the current conditions. The rub is, so that’s the technical answer, this is the right answer, technically. Practically, just make sure, when you go through and do the valuation today as the current exercise, that gathering the data was relatively easy. That if somebody else, not you, had to do this, they could.
And then, as we build the actual plan, we’ve got to account for the risk. When you think about accounting for the risk from death versus disability, they’re both disasters, but in one, you’re maybe still around in some capacity, and in the other you’re not. You also have the contingency plan scenario. Death and disability is definitely more risky and less desirable than retirement. So how do we actually account for that risk? It’s not discounting the value. That’s very, very rare. Instead, we do it through the deal terms, over here on the right-hand side: this retention clause.
Most of the deals are funded out of cash flow. Maybe we’ve got some life insurance that acts as the down payment. You have very few deals where there’s an actual cash down payment not funded by life insurance. Most of it’s funded out of cash flow. It’s a promissory note over 7 to 10 years, and you can see the details here.
My main takeaway is the retention clause. If I’m going to commit to buy your business because you maybe died at some point, how do I account for the risk? If you’re worth $3 million at retirement, you must be worth less than that if you suddenly up and die on me and I have to take this thing over with no notice? No! Not a chance. You are not worth less. The business is not worth less because of death and disability. It could be, but we handle it through a retention clause, where we say we’re gonna value your business, and you’re worth $3 million. Retired, dead, disabled, you’re worth $3 million. However, we acknowledge there’s risk. We’re not stupid. There is risk, and we’re gonna account for it through the deal terms.
We’re gonna say, at the end of the first year after closing, so you died, I bought it, I took it over, one year later, if we have 90% of the clients and the revenue that we thought we should have, your estate gets paid on time and as planned, as it should. You took the steps, you told your clients who I was, they know why I’d be calling. You have a letter from the grave that goes to those clients saying, hey, if you remember, we went through and did this planning work, and if you’re reading this letter, something horrible has happened. It’s not uncommon to retain close to 100%, even in death and disability. But if I’m buying your business, I definitely want a retention clause just in case.
So that covers how they’re funded. Most of the time, again, it’s a promissory note. You do want to try to account for the risk, but I would do it through the retention clause. That’s the most common answer. And usually, again, Julia on our team, for example, who would work with you through this process with our counsel, would write a retention clause that says one year after closing, 90% retention or better is the target, based on revenue. Those are the most common metrics. There are variations we can use, but those are the most common.
And then we’ve got to make sure we write this thing down and get it signed by the end of the year. But don’t stop there. Again, we’ve got a great team and great resources. They’ll even point out to you, maybe not by the end of this year, but start thinking about your contingency file. Just the practical elements. If you were suddenly gone, how do we get into your computer, payroll, your filing cabinet, if you still have one of those? How do we get into your office? You’d be surprised at the stuff we’ve dealt with. A great buy-sell, well thought out, but all of a sudden nobody has a key to your office, and they can’t find your set, and so we’re locked out, and we kind of need to get in there the day after. So we’ll help you with the technical side, the contracts, the taxes, the funding, but we’ll also help you think through the practical, because we’ve seen this stuff play out. We’ve seen it work well, and we’ve seen it not work so well.
David Grau Jr.: The other side of the same coin is retirement, vertically, on your feet, where you get to exit. Here there are four main variables. I’m not going to spend a lot of time on this, but I want to plant the seed and get you thinking about it. I’ll put it in the upper right-hand corner for you now: this is the stuff to start thinking about, because it will influence some of the stuff I’m going to talk about here in a few slides, so I just want you to start ruminating on it. Getting a little parched.
So, four variables. Starting from the left here, real quick: practice size. Why does that matter for your eventual exit options, and who you maybe sell to? Well, if you’re listening to today’s session, and maybe you’re a couple of years from retirement, and you’ve got half a million in revenue, whether that’s fees, 12b-1s, trails, I don’t care, but half a million in revenue, at that size we’re not big enough to necessarily sell internally, because we’re not going to have enough staff to make that viable. So the size factor alone, if I’ve got a great, lean, mean lifestyle business, well, then I’m probably not selling internally. That’s just not in the cards. So I’m probably gonna sell externally. Am I gonna sell it to private equity? Not at $500,000 in revenue, I’m not. Even if I could get an offer from an aggregator, maybe, who’s private equity backed, it’s not going to be attractive. They’re just not looking for practices that size. So it’s going to be a peer-to-peer sale. Great. Just based on practice size, I already know who my hypothetical universe of buyers could be.
Add a zero to my equation. So now we’re at $5 million in revenue, trending towards 10. Well, at that size, I could maybe sell to my internal team. I could still sell to a peer. I could probably sell to private equity, maybe an industry aggregator. I have a lot more choices.
So we go to the next variable, timeline. Well, if my timeline is selling in the next three or four years, internal succession’s off the table. That’s not enough time. Is it enough time for private equity? That’s cutting it close. It’s probably going to be a peer-to-peer sale. So each of these variables influences who you sell to.
The thing I want you to think most about, initially, is actually even easier than these four pointers. It’s kind of my last pointer on here, expanding on the long-term priorities, and that is: which of these do you care most about, if you had to pick one? And eventually you will have to pick one, or you’re gonna just kind of get a moderate deal on all three. Do you want the best price, the best terms, the best taxes, or the best fit? I’m gonna focus here on price, terms, and fit as the top three.
I would tell you, if I’m in your shoes listening, I would focus on fit. Now, again, we’re an organization that, when the time comes, can help you list your practice to get the best price and terms, but focus on fit. If you get the right fit, we can probably get the best price and terms as well, or at least close to it. But if price is your top priority, that will influence who we talk to and how we negotiate that deal. Your terms will be a little more flexible to get the most value out of it for you, because you told us that’s your priority.
The worst thing you can do, regardless of whether we have the pleasure of working together or not, as you contemplate your exit, be that in 12 months or 12 years, is to start by saying, you know what, my top priority is fit, and then start getting into it and shift your priorities. That is where you will enjoy the process the least. Pick your top priority, stick to it, and we’ll optimize for everything else, but we’ve got to know what the top priority is.
So again, these are not Q4 or Q1 to-dos, but I do want you to start thinking about them, because they will influence the things I’m talking about on the next two or three slides. As you think about this, your options are actually relatively simple, regardless of what we try to optimize for. Again, we’re optimizing for price, terms, or fit. But either way, we’re gonna sell internally to our team, if we have enough time, and you can see the rough time frame estimates down there at the bottom. Or I can sell externally to a peer, an aggregator, or PE, depending, again, on size, timeline, and a variety of factors. Or I could do a merger. But you have options, depending on your size, your time frame, and your priorities. So all these things together, as you start thinking about this at some point in Q4 or Q1, will help you make more informed decisions as you progress.
David Grau Jr.: Speaking of progressing, let’s hit entity formation, because if you’re in growth mode, trying to merge practices in, grow organically, expand your team, and maybe start sharing equity, or selling, entity formation is the least exciting subject, but it really, really is impactful. And here’s what I would encourage you to do: in Q1, get this stuff upgraded.
If you already have an entity, and I suspect most of you listening probably do, you have an LLC, you have an S-Corp of some shape or size. Maybe you use it for everything in the business. All your cash flow is in and out of this thing, it’s where all your expenses are. You’re running an optimized business. You’ve got a good, clean P&L. The problem I see with this a lot, especially when I talk to our succession planning team, or our merger team, or even our acquisition team, and this stuff comes up in a variety of different places, is that the business entity, the way you’re operating today, worked when you formed the company 10 years ago. But now you’re at half a billion, $10 billion in assets under management, and if we could start over, what you have now is not what we would recommend. In fact, oftentimes you would look at it and say, yeah, fair.
So let’s focus on upgrading it in Q1, because these things do take time. We don’t want to rush this. This is not a Q4 priority. But you’ve got to think about whether the entity structure you have now fits. The thing I would focus on is right here at the bottom, our pro tip, and that is: build the entity, or rebuild it, and we do a lot of that work and can help you convert what you have, for where your business is going, not where it started, or frankly, not even where it’s at now.
The nice thing is, here, I’ll give you the answer to the test. For almost every single one of you listening, and I would generally just say for all of you listening, but maybe there’s some outlier circumstance where this isn’t right, in almost all cases, this is the optimized structure. It’s an LLC, taxed as a partnership, assuming there’s more than one of you. That is the primary operating entity. This is where all client ownership resides: revenue, profits, everything is right here. However, instead of the three of you in my example owning the LLC together, we’re going to layer in three individual S-Corps, and those S-Corps are going to be the owners in the LLC. So you’ll see me down here on the left. I own an S-Corp, and my S-Corp owns the interest in the LLC.
This structure is really nice, because it gives you all of the upsides of the LLC, whether you’re a growing firm or a shrinking firm, and not shrinking as in your revenue, but shrinking as in you want to get out of it and take chips off the table. Growth mode on the front nine, or retirement mode on the back nine, this structure will benefit you directly or indirectly. The LLC is a really, really useful tool.
I won’t even worry about getting questions on this, because we will get questions at some point if I don’t mention it. You think, well, why wouldn’t I just set up the LLC and have it taxed as an S-Corp? Then I don’t need three more S-Corps down here at the bottom. Because as soon as you have the S-Corp election, we lose all the cool features of the LLC that I promise you will want and need, if not today, then in the future. But then, by virtue of sticking to an LLC taxed as a partnership, we lose all the tax benefits of the S-Corp. But we pick them up down here.
So this structure works really, really well. Big firms, small firms, growing firms, firms beginning their exit strategy and their off-ramp, you cannot beat this structure. I’ve yet to find a superior model. And it’s really not all that complicated. It’s a little more nuanced, but all we have here is an LLC owned by S-Corps, so the documents and the structure have to be thought out, set up correctly, and optimized for this industry. But I’m not talking about some crazy Cook Islands trust that we’re using here, or offshore bank accounts. This is layering in two very pedestrian tools, but layered together, you really get some synergies.
And the great thing is, as you look at this and think, wow, this is interesting, but my CPA’s never said anything, usually when you go show them this diagram, or we have a much more detailed diagram that you can show them, they look at it and say, yeah, it’s a good strategy that would work really well for you. And you think, well, why didn’t my CPA tell me that? Because most of you are working with a tax filer, not a tax strategist. So think about it, explore it. This will help, I promise.
David Grau Jr.: A couple of other to-dos. These are priorities I would say to try to get figured out this year, and the first is advisor compensation. It’s been one of the areas that’s had the most change in the last couple of years. So what are we seeing change, and why do you care?
Well, teams are shifting away from payouts for their advisors. I think you know what I mean, but by that I mean, if you’ve got three advisors on your team, and you’re paying them out 40% of the production for the book they’re servicing, but you mostly assigned them the book that they’re servicing. Maybe they’ve got a few clients here and there, a broken clock’s right twice a day. If you assigned them most of that book, and they are operating as what we would affectionately call a farmer, they’re servicing the book of business that you’ve assigned. They’re tending the homestead. They’re not hunters. Their main priority is not going out and getting clients, because that’s not what they’re great at. It’s what you’re really good at.
The shift in the industry has been away from giving them a payout like a hunter, someone who goes out and builds their own book of business, and toward the salaried advisor model. I pay you a salary every year, and I give you a bonus. I’m not gonna weight the bonus too heavily on sourcing new business, but I am going to have a bonus structure, and I am going to make sure that we’re contemporary.
The great thing about this structure is, number one, you’re seeing it. It’s not necessarily referred to as the salaried advisor model, or, as we would call it, the BBP, Base, Bonus, and Profits. But if you look under the hood of most ensemble firms, big or small, they’re using some version of this. The best part is, this is critical to supporting true teaming.
Now, this is one of those areas where I’ve seen some really great work done by some of our peer organizations. Angie Herbers and her organization, the Diamond Team model, I love the stuff they’re talking about out there. Philip Palaveev and the Ensemble Practice, the work that they do. But I tell you, if you’re building a great farm team of talent, an ensemble, you’re using diamond teams, but you’re paying your people like a siloed branch model, it’s gonna chafe, and you’re gonna get frustrated.
And you know where this stuff comes up? When you assign somebody a book of business that’s doing, I don’t know, half a million in fees or revenue. And then, for the same 100 households you assigned them, five or six years later, that half-million-dollar book is now generating a million because of market appreciation of the assets. Maybe some additional investable assets came in, but they’re doing the same work for the same number of households, they didn’t really do anything noteworthy, and they’re now getting paid double. You can watch that map and do it again and again. It is not a cost-effective strategy.
So you’re seeing this change, and it’s been changing in a really big way, shifting to a salaried model. But it’s not as easy as just picking a number and making it a salary. The key here is that it’s not tied to revenue on a regular basis. We can still correlate it to revenue. Let’s call a spade a spade. If you’re managing a million in fees for me, of clients I’ve assigned to you, you’re probably, between you, me, and the wall, gonna get a salary that’s $190,000, $210,000, give or take. That equates to about a 20 to 25% payout. But we’re gonna set the salary annually. We’re gonna have pay bands based on the amount of assets that I have assigned you to service. It’s gonna be really easy, and you’re not gonna have to update it.
The other great thing is we’ve got data from our thousands of valuation data points on compensation. So it’s not survey data. When we do our comp research for you, it’s something you can actually rely on. It’s interesting to look at some of the survey data that’s out there, but if I go look at, like, the Schwab study and the InvestmentNews Moss Adams study, look at the sample size. You could rely on survey data if you had large numbers, if you had thousands of advisors submitting, but you don’t. You have a couple hundred. It’s not reliable. So I would lean into getting good data from things like valuations. I’m not going to say the valuation data is audited before they give it to us, but people spend a lot more time on giving us valuation data and comp data for their teams than they do on a survey.
The nice thing is, if you build these plans right, which we do and you would with us, they don’t require you to update them annually. These things can be future-proofed. You might check in every couple of years just to make sure it’s calibrated, but that’s it. It’s really, really easy to set up and deploy.
There are a number of other features here, and I’ll just put them up on screen for you. We don’t have to spend a lot of time on it today, because, again, these slides are available to you. But I tell you, if you do the math, if you take the before and after, so let’s say the production-based model on the left is paying out their advisor team maybe $1.3 million, based on a grid, for clients I assigned them. In terms of profits here, we’re doing $650,000. Not terrible, on $3 million in revenue. But fast-forward to the salaried advisor model, using the base, bonus, and profits, BBP, right here at the bottom. Now, all of a sudden, our advisor compensation is more like a million, and that leaves us more in the way of profits. That has a huge impact on the valuation of your business. Think about current valuation multiples, which I’ll talk more about here in a bit. If you can drop an extra $50,000 or $100,000 to the bottom line, times 9 or 10, it adds up quickly.
So, that’s compensation planning. We literally do whole webinars on that topic, so I’m only giving it a glancing blow, just touching the surface of this topic. But if it’s a priority for you and you want to talk more about it, just let us know.
David Grau Jr.: The other one pertains to your staff, because you can’t grow these firms without people, without talent, without advisors. That’s the human capital component, and I really want to make sure we can give you some best practices here, and hopefully this year help you get some new documents in place with your advisor staff who are client-facing, to protect your business. You can’t grow and scale these businesses without people. The problem is, as you bring people in, and you mentor and train them, and they’re doing a great job servicing the book, the equity kind of transfers over time, because the client relationship moves from you to them.
So how do we protect it? Well, I’ll put your typical answers right down the middle of the field, up on screen. Non-competes. You knew it was coming. Now, I know this is a webinar for all of you throughout the US. Some of you are inevitably in California. Washington just did this, which means California, Washington did it, and Oregon’s gonna do it. New York. There are a bunch of states where it’s almost impossible to enforce a non-compete. In fact, I’ll put this graphic up on screen for you. If you look at the number of states that have no restrictions around non-competes, there aren’t many. I might need two hands, but I’m gonna have some fingers left over. The truth is, most states have some restrictions around this topic.
So if you run top to bottom here, non-competes limit somebody’s ability to compete with you fairly in the industry. You don’t care about that one. A, it’s hard to enforce. B, it’s gonna make it really hard to recruit. And it doesn’t solve your problem. What you’re really concerned about is one of your key team members, who you’ve mentored and trained and who’s been working with clients, leaving and taking those clients with them.
Well, then I’m gonna make sure I have a non-solicit that says they can’t solicit business from those clients. That one’s not super practical either. If you’re listening today and you’re affiliated with a broker-dealer, i.e., dealing with FINRA, you’ve got Rule 2140 to contend with, which means you can’t stop them from working with who they want to work with. Second, it’s too easy to circumvent. If I have relationships with my clients, and I’m connected with them on LinkedIn and Facebook, they know me, I know them, they’ve got my cell phone, all I have to do is tell them my new phone number, email, maybe address. I’m not soliciting them for any business, just updating contact information. It’s too easy to circumvent, so that one’s not super helpful.
You can go to maybe a no-service clause, where we say, well, I don’t care who solicited who, you just can’t do business with firm clients. Again, if you’re listening and affiliated with a broker-dealer under FINRA, you can’t do that one either. Plus, it’s tough to enforce, because a no-service clause is just another version of a non-compete. So it’s gonna be hard to enforce.
Well, then we can jump down to things like non-disclosure agreements and confidentiality terms in your employment contract. We would definitely build that in and encourage it. That is enforceable, and it can actually offer you some protections. Then there’s non-disparagement: just don’t say nasty things about each other. Maybe a buyout, where we just say, hey, you know what, if you take clients, it’s fine. It sucks, we’d rather keep them, but you’re just gonna pay us for them. That’s another version of a non-compete, because inversely, if you don’t pay us for them, then I’m saying you can’t take them. Well, that’s a non-compete.
So what in the world do we do? Are we just left with a confidentiality clause? Maybe. Buyouts can actually still work in some states, for sure, a handful of them. But your secret weapon here, which we use a lot, which is lethally effective, and which is kind of stupid simple once I say it out loud, is garden leave. Most folks don’t know what it is, and they don’t have it in their employment contracts. You’ve got to draft this stuff correctly, but if you do garden leave correctly, what we’re saying is: if and when you resign, we agreed when I hired you that I’m gonna give you three months’ pay. I’m gonna keep you on payroll for three months.
They’re gonna see it as a benefit when they come on board. When they resign and think they’re gonna go compete and take some clients with them, then they realize, shoot, this garden leave thing actually works against me. Because now they’re gonna stay at home. You don’t want them in the office, you don’t need them in the office. They’re at home, and they’re still on payroll, so they still have a duty of loyalty to you as their employer. That’s enforceable. They can’t be out there competing with you, setting up their own independent RIA while on payroll with you, maybe getting a salary. Can’t do it.
So yes, it sucks, because we have to pay them for a month, two months, three months, and we can figure out what amount makes the most sense, and they’re not doing anything. But also, they’re not doing anything. We can ice the kicker here. I’m not a football guy, but I know the analogy. If they’re locked out for three months sitting at home gardening, or doing whatever they do for the next three months, getting paid, that gives you a really good head start. So there are ways to protect your business.
David Grau Jr.: But I’ll call this the stick. Let’s talk about the carrot. The carrot’s far more exciting, and it’s gonna help you, frankly, with recruiting. Because if you can leverage your equity and figure out maybe a partnership track for your organization, with real equity or phantom equity, and I’ll unpack those things here in a second, you may never need to worry about the employment agreement. Still have it. It’s nice to have it and have the stick in case you need to lean into it. But if you can figure out a way to do it with a carrot, golden handcuffs, that’s far more effective.
So when you start thinking about sharing equity, it’s not a one-size-fits-all approach. I’ll put this up on screen for you. You’ve got phantom equity and some of its features, and you have real equity and some of its features. This goes back to my earlier comment around entity formation. If you have the structure I showed you, an LLC taxed as a partnership, owned by S-Corps, well, we actually have a number of different tools on the equity front, like with real equity.
So, if we look at this, we do want our team to think and act more like owners, we do want to retain them long term, and we do have a number of different tools. Depending, again, on how you’re set up, you have more or fewer tools. But you all have access to, and can set up, a phantom equity plan. You’ll hear the terms synthetic equity, phantom equity, and sometimes you’ll even hear these things referred to as deferred comp. All the same thing.
I already put this up on screen for you earlier with the features. The benefit of phantom equity as a starting place for your equity sharing program is, one, we’re never going to call it phantom equity. With your team, this will be a stock appreciation rights plan, or a liquidation rights plan. Don’t call it a fake equity plan, I promise. It doesn’t matter how cool the plan is, no one’s gonna be excited about participating in your fake equity plan. So we’re gonna call it something much better, because it is something much better. But at its core, between you and me, it’s a phantom equity plan.
It’s not real ownership. It kind of feels like it, but it’s not real ownership. They don’t get any decision-making power, there’s no voting, there are no financials you have to share, and they don’t get any profits. They just get a stake in the value in the future, if they’re here when it vests. And the only way the phantom equity vests is if you say it does. We write it down in the plan, but you’ll usually write down vesting criteria like sale of the company, change of control, your death or disability, stuff that’s really far out.
Let’s say they’ve been with you a long time, and they’ve accumulated, I don’t know, a $100,000 phantom equity balance. If they get a better job offer, and they quit and leave, it’s forfeited. It has not vested yet. So that helps them avoid paying taxes, which is great, but it also is your golden handcuffs.
So as you think about phantom equity versus real equity, there are a couple of other layers here. I wanted to put this up for you, just to show that most people start, and they should, with phantom equity. And you can see the most frequent is the appreciation rights plan: equity appreciation rights if it’s an LLC, stock appreciation rights if it’s an S-Corp, but same thing. Almost literally the same thing. But there are other options, and we’ll work through those together as a team. You don’t have to figure this stuff out before you hire us. Our fees are the same no matter what plan type we end up with. Our job is to help you figure out the right plan, and then get it set up and tailored.
On the real equity side, again, I’m not going to spend a lot of time on this, but I will mention that if you are an LLC, like I mentioned, then you can do Class A, B, C, and D, which is where we would generally start with you, where you have the equity you would have, with voting rights, but we get a bunch of different options that you can start leaning into over time. These become really, really useful tools.
And if you layer these things together, your appreciation rights plan and your real equity plan, you can create a path to partnership that could last, I don’t know, 10 or 15 years. You can see here I put an example of a career track, at least by title, up at the top: paraplanner, to servicing advisor, to lead, to senior advisor. After a couple of years with you, when they move to the lead advisor role, you might let them participate in the appreciation rights plan. They’re in that plan for four or five years, and they accumulate $50,000 as an account balance. They can’t do anything with it yet, because it’s not vested, but they have it.
We let the elite few convert that balance to real equity. They can either convert it as a down payment and then pay for more, or they can just convert it to real equity and get their $50,000 worth. Now they’re in the real equity plan, but you’ll notice over here on the left, we’re an LLC, so we have a lot of different options: A, B, C share classes, membership classes. They convert, they get real equity, but it’s non-voting. They do get profits, and they do get a stake in the value, but no vote. And then, again, as we move further up the pyramid, for the elite group here, some of them can get converted to full equity rights, where they have voting rights.
If you lay this path out, A, not everyone needs to participate all the way through to the voting interest. Nor should they. But you can put the carrot out there. It’s an amazing retention tool, and it will really be a differentiator. I think for probably the next 5 to 10 years, this will be a differentiator that will help you attract better talent and retain your top talent. Almost an unfair advantage compared to your peers that are not dealing with this topic.
David Grau Jr.: Let’s wrap up with valuation trends. Again, I’ve talked a lot about protecting your value, but I haven’t actually told you what your value is. So, a couple of high-level observations, and I’ll give you the current multiples.
Larger firms now have three values to consider, and I’ve indirectly talked about this earlier. You have the value to your internal team. That’s one value. You have the value to a peer, the synergistic value, where we combine our businesses and dump some of the excess overhead. And then you have your PE value. For bigger firms, doing a couple million in revenue and above, all three might be options for you. Now, again, they’re not the same answer. They can get close if you start the planning early enough. The important thing is to know they are different, and I think you can understand why. In the internal sale, we’re taking your current business as it exists, and we’re gonna try to sell a stake in it, so nothing changes. In the peer-to-peer sale, we don’t need two receptionists, we don’t need two CRM systems, so we have a consolidation event. That’s why we call it a synergistic sale. And then you’ve got the private equity deal, where the deal terms take eight pages to explain, but they support a really high multiple. But only because the deal terms are so different. So all three are options, and all three are out there. Again, it depends on size, but it’s worth noting.
The other one is that buyers are getting a lot more creative, and they’re getting a lot more experienced. A lot of buyers we’ve worked with have done a deal or two before. Maybe not huge deals, but they’ve bought before. That puts you at a disadvantage if you’re listening and thinking of yourself today as a seller, or maybe a soon-to-be seller. You’ll never do it enough times to get good at it, kind of by design. So make sure you have a good team, like SRG, supporting you through this process, so that you’re always the smartest person in the room on this topic.
As far as current multiples go, I’m gonna give you two different sets of them. First, the easy math: the top-line recurring revenue multiple is 3.27. That’s where we’re at right now. We will be updating this number in our January webinar, and I encourage you to register for it. You’ll actually see it popping up in the chat if you want to get registered. We update this number every single year based on all the transaction data from our deals and all the transaction data from the industry lenders. It’s a good cross-section of the industry and what’s happening.
But it’s 3.27 on your last 12 months of recurring revenue. So, again, in my example, we’ll keep it simple: if you’re a million-dollar fee-only RIA, I just told you that on average you’re worth $3.27 million. The problem is that the range is anywhere between, like, 2 and 4.5, depending on the quality of the book and the terms. But averages are still useful. So this is on top-line revenue. It’s useful if you’re estimating the value of a business with, I don’t know, a million, maybe $2 million in revenue at most.
As you get above that, we’re not valuing a book of business anymore. We’re valuing a business, and businesses are priced based on their earnings. So I put up on screen for you earnings before interest, taxes, depreciation, and amortization. The current multiple, and I don’t think this one will change a lot, even looking at the transactions happening this year that we’ll publish in January, is 9.98. Call it 10 times earnings. That’s been pretty stable, and I don’t think it’ll change a lot, but this is for pricing a business. If you’re selling your practice, and it’s got staff, systems, and processes, and you’re expecting the buyer to take it over, they’re gonna price it based on the earnings, the number at the bottom of your P&L.
The interesting thing, and why I told you at the very beginning to do your valuation annually, is what happens if we can adjust some of these things. We can increase your recurring revenue. We focus on growth until retirement. We’re benchmarking your value every year, and what’s measured improves. We do multi-generational planning. We do a partial book sale, we get rid of the C and D clients, and value keeps going up. That buys us free time, so we increase our client touches, even as we’re getting closer to retirement. We redo our branding. We shift away from Grau & Associates to Succession Resource Group, a brand that can continue after my retirement. We focus on profitability, just cleaning things up a lot. Not laying people off, not cutting major expenses. But if we can increase our profitability and get those employment agreements in place, we can add a lot of value to this business in a relatively short amount of time.
It really is possible, and this is why I would encourage you, whether it’s with us or somebody else, to track that value every year. It’s not for the value per se, it’s the KPIs, the key performance indicators. That’s what you want to be tracking. And it’s nice to see it manifested in a meaningful way.
So, putting a bow on this thing and wrapping it up, you can see the year-end scorecard. Run through this stuff on your own and just see: contingency, your entity, all the way down to the annual valuation. Where do you land? Are there any items we can help you with before the end of the year, or in Q1? All the things we can help with are, frankly, the things I’ve been talking about today, or else I wouldn’t have talked about them or shared the data with you. So when you’re ready: compensation plan design, employment contracts. These all, directly or indirectly, make buying, selling, and the value of your business better.
David Grau Jr.: So, let’s get to questions. I answered a few of them organically in the presentation today, which is fantastic. And then obviously, with my assistance and the moderator, we tried to give you some typed answers. There are two that I didn’t get to that I’ll hit on here real quick, so if you have to drop, fantastic. Again, the recording will be available to you anyway.
The first one I didn’t get to is: if I sign a contingency plan with a peer before the end of the year, December 31, does that lock me into selling to them later, or can I still pursue an internal sale or a PE deal? That often comes up in the contingency work we do, so I’m glad you asked it. The short answer is, generally, no, it does not lock you in. Have I seen Julia and her team, with Meg, and Heidi and Sarah on our legal team, build in a death and disability plan that also addresses retirement? Sure. But it’s maybe, and they could give you a better answer, a quarter of the time. It’s probably less than that. Most of the time, the death and disability plan is just for death and disability. It’s a one-year contract that automatically renews, but you can cancel it with notice. So you could end up selling to that person, but you don’t have to.
And that’s important, because a lot of times your death and disability partner today is not the person you would ultimately want to sell to. I might want to sell to my son or daughter, or my key team, and they’re just not ready yet. So it would make a lot of sense to put a plan in place for death and disability with a peer who knows how to run a business and take care of clients, and then eventually I can convert my death and disability plan to be with my team when they’re ready. So, anyway, long answer for a short question. That is a good one, though. There are multiple layers to it.
Last question, just in terms of time here, to get you guys out of here, but it’s worth addressing for the group: we’re a $3 million RIA leaning towards appreciation rights for two advisors. That helps. If we also convert to an LLC taxed as a partnership in Q1, should the equity plan wait for the new entity, or can we launch both at the same time?
I’ll give you the practical and the technical. Technically, yes, you can definitely do both at the same time, no issues. The appreciation rights plan, or any kind of phantom equity plan, tracks with the real equity. So if we mess around with the real equity, the phantom plan just tracks with it and automatically adjusts, so that’s not a big deal.
Practically, I would tackle the entity first, and then the equity sharing. I’m not saying it’s too much, but unless there’s some pressing need to get this done and figured out by the end of Q1, I would get the entity stuff done, put that to bed, and then pick up the work on the equity sharing plan, just because it’ll be a lot more manageable conceptually if you do it in a more linear fashion. We can obviously handle it. We have various teams and pods that are all experts, and they all work together, so it’s not a capacity issue on our side. It’s just mental capacity: do you want to try to deal with all of this at the same time? For a lot of clients, we do, and we manage it, and it’s fine. But knowing we’re talking about Q4 and Q1, if I’m dealing with it in that time frame, I’d probably focus on one, then the other.
David Grau Jr.: So, folks, I appreciate you asking the questions you did during the session, as I encouraged you to do, and participating in the poll at the very beginning. Just wrapping up with the same housekeeping I started with: the session was recorded, and you will get it in your inbox automatically tomorrow. The slides are available if you’d like a copy of them. Just reply back to our team when they reach out, and you’ll hear from them. Short of that, if you got useful information out of this session and you want to get started, again, our team will be pinging you anyway, so just let us know. We’re happy to be a resource, whether it’s in Q4, Q1, or at some point in 2027.
We hope this session gave you some good, actionable priorities and helped you figure out what to do now versus a little bit later. And at the end of the day, whether you’re ready to retire now, or it’s 20 years out and maybe you’re still in growth mode, really, everything I’ve touched on here today is important for all of you listening. The succession component might be further out for some of you, so you could put that one off. But the entity, the comp plan design, all of that stuff, the death and disability plan, those are all mission critical for every one of us as business owners.
So, we hope that was helpful. Appreciate you joining us. Stay tuned for our January webinar. It’s our big one, where we update you on current M&A trends, multiples, and deal structures. But for today, that’s a wrap.
What Should Your Practice Finish Before December 31, and What Can Wait for Q1?
Close what is open before year-end, and start what takes time in Q1. Your contingency plan, employment agreements and next year's compensation plan belong on the December list. Your entity, equity plan and valuation refresh take longer, so they start in Q1.
In this session, Succession Resource Group's David Grau Jr., MBA, Founder & CEO, lays out a year-end playbook for advisory firm owners: what to finish now and what to start in the new year.
David explains why life insurance is not a contingency plan and how a retention clause, not a discount, handles the risk of a sudden exit. He shows the LLC owned by S-Corps structure he recommends for growing firms, how a base, bonus and profits compensation model can lift profit from 22% to 33% of revenue on a $3M firm, and why garden leave is often more enforceable than a non-compete. He maps phantom and real equity into a 15-year path to partnership and closes with current valuation multiples of 3.27x recurring revenue and 9.98x EBITDA. Owners heading into planning season who want a clear Q4 and Q1 priority list will find this a practical roadmap.
Host
David Grau Jr., MBA, Founder & CEO
David Grau Jr. is the founder and CEO of Succession Resource Group, a succession and M&A consulting firm for financial advisors. A published author, U.S. Navy veteran, and one of the industry's most recognized voices on advisor M&A and next-generation building strategies, David has delivered more than 200 presentations at leading financial services firms nationwide.
Frequently Asked Questions
What should advisory firm owners finish before December 31?
A signed and funded contingency plan, employment agreements in writing for client-facing advisors, and a compensation plan set for the new year. These close out work that is already open, and most can be completed in a few weeks.
Is life insurance enough for a contingency plan?
No. Insurance can fund a plan, but it does not name a successor, set a value or protect client relationships. A working plan sets the value, decides how it is funded, puts the agreement in writing, is shared with clients and staff, and is reviewed every year. Most are funded from cash flow through a promissory note, with a retention clause that accounts for the risk of a sudden exit.
What entity structure works best for a growing advisory firm?
For most firms, an LLC taxed as a partnership as the operating entity, with each owner holding their interest through their own S-Corp. The LLC keeps the flexibility you need for equity sharing, mergers and multiple member classes, and the S-Corps keep the tax benefits. Start the change in Q1, since amendments and tax elections take weeks.
Should I offer phantom equity or real equity to my team?
Most firms start with phantom equity, usually an appreciation rights plan. It gives key people a stake in future value without ownership, voting or shared financials, and it is easy to modify. In SRG's experience, 64% of firms choose phantom equity. Real equity can come later as part of a career track, often non-voting first and voting for a select few.


